RECENT STORIES:

Addressing digital sovereignty in a data-driven world
GenAI chatbot sycophancy persists as makers struggle to manage
TRINASOLAR DEBUTS ELEMENTA 3, EXCLUSIVE AUSTRALIAN PANEL AT ALL ENERGY...
A Global Stage, Infinite Echoes: 2025 Chery International User Summit ...
PINTEC Announces Changes in the Board of Directors
EVCharge Live Indonesia and Mobility Live Indonesia 2025 to Drive the ...
LOGIN REGISTER
DigiconAsia
  • Features
    • Featured

      Leveraging CRM platform for AI-powered financial inclusion in Asia

      Leveraging CRM platform for AI-powered financial inclusion in Asia

      Friday, October 17, 2025, 2:34 PM Asia/Singapore | Features
    • Featured

      From smart cities to strained cities?

      From smart cities to strained cities?

      Thursday, October 16, 2025, 1:43 PM Asia/Singapore | Data Centers & Interconnectivity, Features
    • Featured

      Storage for AI, AI for storage

      Storage for AI, AI for storage

      Tuesday, October 7, 2025, 3:57 PM Asia/Singapore | Features
  • News
    • Featured

      Zero click vulnerability found within a day in new AI-powered browser

      Zero click vulnerability found within a day in new AI-powered browser

      Friday, October 24, 2025, 3:18 PM Asia/Singapore | News, Newsletter
    • Featured

      Can poor social media content cause irreversible GenAI brain rot?

      Can poor social media content cause irreversible GenAI brain rot?

      Thursday, October 23, 2025, 4:06 PM Asia/Singapore | News, Newsletter
    • Featured

      Gaming industry hit hard by layoffs and closures amid AI gold rush

      Gaming industry hit hard by layoffs and closures amid AI gold rush

      Wednesday, October 22, 2025, 4:36 PM Asia/Singapore | News
  • Perspectives
  • Tips & Strategies
  • Whitepapers
  • Awards 2023
  • Directory
  • E-Learning

Select Page

News

Fake citations spark debate over Newfoundland education plan

By DigiconAsia Editors | Tuesday, September 16, 2025, 2:31 PM Asia/Singapore

Fake citations spark debate over Newfoundland education plan

A 418-page education reform recommendation that took academics 18 months to prepare, has sparked controversy over 15 hallucinated citations, undermining credibility.

A 418-page document (released in August 2025) on a 10-year plan for Newfoundland and Labrador’s Education Accord has drawn controversy last week (13 Sep 2025) after journalists and educators identified at least 15 fake citations in it.

This has sparked concerns over academic integrity and the misleading use of technology in policymaking. The document is the culmination of 18 months’ work by professors at Memorial University’s Faculty of Education, alongside Education Minister Bernard Davis, backed by 110 recommendations and informed by 9,000 surveys and the input of 400 educators.

Yet its credibility now faces scrutiny over references to non-existent films, scholarly articles, and research — some lifted from style guides that explicitly state their examples are fictitious.

Fake citations spark AI debate
Canada’s CBC News and Radio-Canada had carried the first reports of omissions and fictitious sources in the document, noting that educators reviewing the document suspect that the use of generative AI may have resulted in ‘hallucinated’ references being included during preparation.

One infamous example was a citation for a National Film Board production “Schoolyard Games” (2008), which both the film board and academic sources confirmed never existed.

Josh Lepawsky, a former Memorial University Faculty Association president, has noted: “Errors happen. Created citations are a completely different matter that undermines the credibility of the material,” warning that this breaches basic scholarly standards.

Education Minister Bernard Davis has responded that only about 15 out of nearly 450 total citations were found to be fraudulent, labeling the mistakes as “disheartening” but asserting that they have had no influence on the report’s policy recommendations. Davis has further denied any direct AI involvement, calling the idea “preposterous”,  although his lack of clarity on how such references were inserted has only deepened doubts among educators and journalists.

An ironic sign of the times
The 10-year roadmap outlined in the document is meant to promote digital literacy, responsible technology use, and privacy awareness as core goals for learners in Newfoundland and Labrador’s schools.

Critics now say that the presence of fabricated citations within the document undermine these very goals, modeling the very hazards of misinformation and false credibility that responsible digital citizenship aims to correct.

The people responsible for the errors have promised to review and amend the affected sections, while defenders of the report say the problematic citations represent a small fraction of an otherwise comprehensive, well-researched document.

However, teachers’ organizations and academic critics argue that any instance of fabricated evidence — whether by human error or automated tools — calls into question the seriousness with which technology’s risks are being addressed in public sector governance.

Share:

PreviousResearch breakthrough allows one-shot W state measurement, unlocks new quantum computing possibilities
NextFamily Offices in Asia Pacific Prioritize Next-Gen Education Amidst Wealth Transfer, Demonstrate Proactive Response to Market Volatility: Citi Wealth 2025 Survey Reveals

Related Posts

Singapore telco taps into cloud data analytics platform

Singapore telco taps into cloud data analytics platform

May 11, 2020

Can smart video technology make hybrid working more equitable?

Can smart video technology make hybrid working more equitable?

May 26, 2022

3 am is the golden hour of online shopping for upcoming Ramadan: report

3 am is the golden hour of online shopping for upcoming Ramadan: report

April 17, 2020

First virtual European business mission to SE Asia to showcase ICT innovations

First virtual European business mission to SE Asia to showcase ICT innovations

September 28, 2020

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Awards Nomination Banner

gamification list

PARTICIPATE NOW

top placement

Whitepapers

  • Achieve Modernization Without the Complexity

    Achieve Modernization Without the Complexity

    Transforming IT infrastructure is crucial …Download Whitepaper
  • 5 Steps to Boost IT Infrastructure Reliability

    5 Steps to Boost IT Infrastructure Reliability

    In today's fast-evolving tech landscape, …Download Whitepaper
  • Simplify Payroll Setup for Your Small Business

    Simplify Payroll Setup for Your Small Business

    In our free guide, "How …Download Whitepaper
  • Overcoming the Challenges of Cost & Complexity in the Cloud-first Era.

    Overcoming the Challenges of Cost & Complexity in the Cloud-first Era.

    Download Whitepaper

Middle Placement

Case Studies

  • Globe Business reduces overall customer service workload by 34% through digitalization

    Globe Business reduces overall customer service workload by 34% through digitalization

    This was the result of …Read More
  • HOSTWAY gains 73% operational efficiency for private cloud operations  

    HOSTWAY gains 73% operational efficiency for private cloud operations  

    With NetApp storage solutions, the …Read More
  • Designing unmanned aerial vehicles for safety and speed

    Designing unmanned aerial vehicles for safety and speed

    SwissDrones uses Autodesk Fusion to …Read More
  • LVMH redefines payments in the global luxury sector with Adyen

    LVMH redefines payments in the global luxury sector with Adyen

    Frictionless payment solutions for seamless …Read More

Bottom Sidebar

Other News

  • TRINASOLAR DEBUTS ELEMENTA 3, EXCLUSIVE AUSTRALIAN PANEL AT ALL ENERGY 2025

    October 27, 2025
    MELBOURNE, Australia, Oct. 26, 2025 …Read More »
  • A Global Stage, Infinite Echoes: 2025 Chery International User Summit Co-Creates a Sustainable Future

    October 26, 2025
    WUHU, China, Oct. 25, 2025 …Read More »
  • PINTEC Announces Changes in the Board of Directors

    October 25, 2025
    BEIJING, Oct. 25, 2025 /PRNewswire/ …Read More »
  • EVCharge Live Indonesia and Mobility Live Indonesia 2025 to Drive the Future of Sustainable Transport

    October 24, 2025
    JAKARTA, Indonesia, Oct. 24, 2025 …Read More »
  • Yiwugo Celebrates Its 13th Anniversary Alongside the Grand Opening of Yiwu’s Gen-6 Market

    October 24, 2025
    —What New Opportunities Wait for …Read More »
  • Our Brands
  • CybersecAsia
  • MartechAsia
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • Terms of Use
  • Advertising & Reprint Policy
  • Media Kit
  • Subscribe
  • Manage Subscriptions
  • Newsletter

Copyright © 2025 DigiconAsia All Rights Reserved.